Status: FED
Lamb Stew + Dates + Couscous
[braised lamb shoulder, shredded, with cumin & coriander, over Israeli couscous & medjool dates]
Brussels sprouts + Fennel + Mandarin
[julienned & blanched brussels, shaved fennel, cilantro, mandarin segments, cilantro]
Beef Shanks + Barley + Beans + Cabbage?
[braised shanks & jus over beans, barley & cabbage]
Cookies
Guest #61.1: Mubin Shaikh
Occupation: Former undercover informant/agent for CSIS/RCMP, grad student, freelance military training (how many resumes do you see like that?)
Distinguishing characteristic: Unguarded
Sent thank-you: email
Guest #61.2: Michelle Shepherd
Occupation: National security reporter for Toronto Star, author of Guantanamo's Child: The Untold Story of Omar Khadr
Contributed: Niagara Mist black cherry pinot noir, saffron from Yemen, #G20 maple syrup
Sent thank-you: Email. First guest to ever ask for transcripts. Glad to share them.
Guest #61.3: Beth Palmer
Occupation: Grad student (but how do we know she’s not an undercover agent sent to infiltrate MY secret society?)
Contributed: Perrin Reserve 2007 Cote du Rhone
Sent thank-you: Email
Guest #61.4: Paul Terefenko
Occupation: Writer and Photographer
Contributed: Jim Bean black cherry whiskey
In some cruel twist of fate, both Michelle and Paul brought me black cherry flavoured booze. I had tasted Paul’s “Red Stag” before. Or rather, I’d placed Jim Bean’s black cherry cough syrup flavoured bourbon in my mouth before spitting it out. It came with the receipt and was returned to the liquor store. Michelle told me that hers was “really, really disgusting. And I would really like you to serve it seriously one night to guests.” It now sits on my shelf, gathering dust with the arcane collection of my grandmother’s sugary liqueurs.
Note to future guests: I do not live with my folk-rock band in a Queen West hovel. I do not collect joke drinks.
And now, because you asked for it, some terror-talk:
Yemen
MINTZ
(at the tail end of explaining dish) … And then saffron at the last moment.
SHAIKH
Yemeni saffron. Probably from thousands of years ago.
MINTZ
How was Yemen?
SHEPHARD
Yemen was great, fascinating. It was, when I went it was pre-Fort Hood, pre-underwear bomber. So it was, there was no attention there.
TEREFENKO
No Wikilieaks, no missile strikes.
SHEPHARD
Exactly.
MINTZ
You had tried to go to Yemen, hadn’t you?
SHAIKH
Yeah.
MINTZ
How old were you?
SHAIKH
In July, 2005.
MINTZ
And at the time, what did you want to go there for?
SHAIKH
(laughs)
SHEPHARD
(laughs)
He’s good. Where’d you pull that out of? That was a good segue?
SHAIKH
I think I can say it. (to Shephard) Can’t I?
SHEPHARD
Well, Corey obviously knows it from somewhere. (to me) But you know it from somewhere, not me. So you must have read that somewhere.
SHAIKH
No. There was only one instance in which that tidbit of information was publicized. And it was very quickly disappeared.
SHEPHARD
Interesting. So Corey, how did you know that he’d gone to Yemen?
Coffee Time
MINTZ
It shocked me how much Coffee Time there was. Coffee Time and Time Hortons.
SHEPHARD
I always sort of want to elevate the coffee meetings to Starbucks. But it just doesn’t happen.
SHAIKH
The thing about the Tim Horton’s especially is that we would have audio transcripts of intercepts from the vehicle, and we’re all pulling up to the Tim Hortons, a bunch of terrorist wannabes, “yeah, I’ll have a french vanilla”. So it’s playing in court.
MINTZ
Any lattes?
SHAIKH
No lattes. But the joke was that, if you want to deal with terrorism, set up a Tim Horton’s.
MINTZ
See, I think that if you’re willing to sacrifice your life to destroy people, if your agenda is terror, that you would drink your coffee black.
Terror & The Media
MINTZ
The underlying motive, or objective, of all those things, is …
SHAIKH
To kill a bunch of people.
MINTZ
Slash, have the effect that action creates, which is terror.
SHAIKH
That’s right. Because media will dutifully respond.
SHEPHARD
Well, but that’s …
SHAIKH
I know …
SHEPHARD
No, no, that’s a good point. Because we, the latest edition, three, of Inspire (the terrorism magazine), they do have this kind of, the more you write about it, the greater prominence you give it.
SHAIKH
“Media coverage gives terrorism a longevity it might not otherwise enjoy.”
SHEPHARD
There’s a point to that. You have to find a balance. You obviously have to report on …
SHAIKH
You can’t censor. And you can’t put everything down. So what do you do? What’s a halfway point of covering terrorism? How do you do that? It’s pretty messy. It’s just that they sit there and that’s what they think about. How do we get this kind of message out to people, killing a bunch of people all at once. How do we do that? And my whole thing is that, these guys will move away from the large scale spectacle attacks. They’ll just realize that they just can’t pull it off. And they’ll just, they’ll go with your regular old mass shooting. Which in the US, happens every week.
Religious Justification
SHEPHARD
I still don’t know how you go from, this is the story I can never, ever get at, what’s that point? In every case it’s a different point. How do you actually justify what you’re doing?
SHAIKH
Yeah, how do you do that?
SHEPHARD
Well, you watched them do it.
SHAIKH
Well, I mean, y’know. I think they’ve come to a point where they want to do something. They want to hurt people. They want to do bad things. And they already know that that’s what they want to do. So whatever justification they’ll find, they’ll use it. So it’s kind of misunderstood when people say, “oh, religion is used.” People will use anything. They’ll use partisanship. They’ll use clothing labels. You name it. If people want to exploit other people, manipulate the situation, they’ll take whatever they have. Any tools that are available, they’ll use it. Whether it’s religion, politics, whatever. Now, you have environmentalists, radical terrorist groups. Look at this. The growing nexus between environmentalists, the native youth movement, first nations militant groups and Hezzbollah. And when asked, Hezzbollah, what are you doing with environmentalists and first nations terrorist groups, say, “oh, we like their politics.” That’s it. There’s a utility in there.

photo by Paul Terefenko
Yemen PT. 2
SHEPHARD
So, you’ve really dodged Corey’s question.
SHAIKH
I actually thought, in the back of my mind …
MINTZ
It was part of a larger question of, what led you to all this. What I’m saying is, I can let you off the hook now, but I’m just going to ask you again later.
SHAIKH
Well, I’m already resolving that I’m going to answer it directly.
I’ll give a little bit of back story to that. I lived in Syria, from ’02 to ’04. And while I was in Syria, I had learned that a lot of western students had been going to Yemen also. Yemen was known as a place for learning traditional Islam. And they have two elements, the militants, and they’re totally extremists and terrorists, and a whole other side, very suffi, like Al Habib Ali Al-Jifri. So I was looking to go to some of those places down there. While I was in Syria, I though, ok, I’m hearing a lot of stories about studying in Yemen, this and that, ok, great.
MINTZ
And at this point, you were pursuing your own spiritual education?
SHAIKH
Yeah, I went to learn Arabic and Islamic studies. It was after 9/11, identity crisis. Like, oh god, what do I do now. And I’m, like, I have the look, the long beard and the robes… I just felt the need to leave. I said, you know what, I’ve had it. Y’know, the west and this and that. I was a spoiled, naïve, idealistic Canadian boy. I went to Syria, in early 2002 to study Arabic and Islamic studies. I was doing a religious studies degree by distance through Waterloo University. Saudi wouldn’t let me in with the books on the bible…
I was there from ’02 to ’04 and that’s when I really realized how good we have it here. That’s what did it for me. People say we’re getting closer to a police state. Buddy, you haven’t lived in a police state…
So while I’m there I’m realizing how good we have it here, in the west, for muslims especially. I come back and Momin Khawaja? Gets arrested. So I phone CSIS …
SHEPHARD
You guys know Momin Khawaja? He’s the one that was in Ottawa. They arrested him in part with the British plot. And he actually was our first terrorism case using the anti-terrorism laws. Just shout if you need names or cases because once we get going …
SHAIKH
But, I grew up with him, when I was younger. I phoned CSIS up and basically said, hey, I know this guy. There must be a mistake.
SHEPHARD
Ok, how do you phone CSIS up?
SHAIKH
That’s what the judge said.
MINTZ
I was wondering about that too. It’s hard enough to reach somebody at the City of Toronto …
SHEPHARD
Exactly. In all honest, how …
SHAIKH
I probably just looked it up. So the guy was like, somebody will get back to you shortly. And sure enough the next day is when the guy came and saw me. This is now 2004.
SHEPHARD
So you’re back from Syria?
SHAIKH
Yeah, March, 2004. I’ll never forget that date. My brother had a Time Horton’s coffee ready for me.
MINTZ
Sort of a, “thanks for not getting radicalized …?”
SHEPHARD
With Timbits.
SHAIKH
Chocolate glazed. Please.
SHEPHARD
Seriously, your brother came to the airport with the Tim Horton’s?
SHAIKH
Oh yeah. I told him in advance. Dude. So anyways, the CSIS guy came. For them it was just, oh, we want you to consult for us. We have access in the community. We will direct you to certain people. We want to know what they’re up to. You tell us if you think they’re a problem or not. So I thought, yeah, that’s not a bad idea. I think you guys need that. You guys need somebody who knows the community, but at the same time, I understand both sides. So then it turned into, ok, different tasks.
MINTZ
You understand both sides because you had already been in the army?
SHAIKH
Yeah, I was in the army cadets, when I was a young boy, from I think, thirteen to nineteen. I think that’s what laid the foundation for the pro-Canada stance and also the militant aspect. So I was doing taskings for them. And in July 2005, they said to me, do you want to go to Yemen? I said sure. I’ve always wanted to go to Yemen.
SHEPHARD
But why did they want you to go to Yemen?
SHAIKH
Well, because there are Canadian students, or Canadian citizens, who are at a “religious school” getting “religious training” and I think it’s well within the right of Canadian government to say, well, who are they, what are they learning, when are they coming back?
Big Decision?
MINTZ
Was it a big decision or was it, ‘sure, why not’?
SHAIKH
It was, yeah, sure, why not. I had just come from a horrible place.
I had this utopian, Isalamist world view, like a lot of these young kids have. They think there’s like this perfect Islamist state out there, somewhere in the middle east. Well it ain’t in the middle east buddy, let me tell you that. It was simply me realizing how good we have it here. So I signed right up man. I had no qualms about it.
SHEPHARD
Because you wanted to defend it?
SHAIKH
I didn’t want people to be doing things whereby the government would have responded in such a way that they would take away a right, religious rights and what not.
Goofball Terrorists
SAIKH
However unattainable, I’ve always been of the position that they could not have possibly pull of what they wanted to pull off. The Toronto 18. They could not have possibly achieve what they wanted to achieve
MINTZ
Because they were inept?
SHAIKH
Well, because it is next to impossible to storm a parliament building, be able to get to the MPs, grab Steven Harper, behead him. That is just impossible.
SHEPHARD
Those were the fanciful ideas.
MINTZ
But if you’ve got a wish list …
SHAIKH
That’s the thing …
MINTZ
You’ll go one step down.
SHAIKH
That’s right. And so this is the problem. As unattainable and unrealistic as it was, that’s what their goal was.
Not Hiding
TEREFENKO
You seem more than just casually available. You just seem completely open. Almost as if you’re … are you trying to get a message out?
SHAIKH
That’s the literal meaning of my name. Mubim. Perspicuous. No beating around the bush. I just realized that I had to do that because it was going to get public and that’s exactly what happened. Everything was laid right out. And if I had tried to hide and dodge, how long was I going to do that for?
Money
SHAIKH
That’s what really set them (the RCMP) off, that I went public. They didn’t like that. Because for them it’s like, we control the story.
MINTZ
But didn’t you hold out for more money before testifying?
SHAIKH
Not hold out. It’s a very important part. Because I was waiting for this in court. And my statement was, I never once said to the RCMP or CSIS or anybody, if you don’t pay me I’m not going to testify, not one time. And they tried. They tried everything.
If you knew then what you know now…?
SHAIKH
For a year and a half I was doing that and I didn’t know what I was getting in to. For me it was just another tasking.
MINTZ
and if you had known from the first request that CSIS had for you, how deep the whole thing was going to go, if you’d know what it was going to cost you, would you have done it?
SHAIKH
Hard to say. I probably still would have gotten involved because I’m just one of those idealistic types. I just think that you’ve got to do the right thing. But it’s so over rated.
SHEPHARD
Doing the right thing is so over rated?
SHAIKH
Yeah. Big time.
SHEPHARD
But come on. Your life now …
SHAIKH
That’s true. I am definitely happier in my skin now, than I was even at the height of my religiousity. That’s what I gained the most out of it. But I lost a lot of standing in the community, instant ostricization. And not just that, but people posting on blogs , I hope you’re found dead in a ditch, your kids, may they all go to hell, curse be on you. It gets depressing when you’re reading that.
MINTZ
It’s not a nice thing to be hated. But you don’t feel in danger though?
SHAIKH
I don’t feel in danger. No. I’m just kind of hoping that nobody’s that stupid.
Halal vs Vegetarian
SHAIKH
My polish wife keeps saying, polish sausages are so good. Before she was Muslim, catholic polish, ate pork. Then became vegetarian, then became Muslim. Now is a completely committed tree hugger hippie Muslim. Organic.
MINTZ
Vegetarian?
SHAIKH
Yeah.
MINTZ
I’d rather, for dietary rules, I’d rather go halal than vegetarian.
PALMER
Corey, you’d rather go anything than vegetarian.
Detox (not the Dr. Dre album)
MINTZ
What’s the detox program?
SHAIKH
Here we go. Theological deprogramming of extremism. It’s taken from social work, cognitive reframing. All it is, is that if you have a particular world view, you’ve shaped it on the basis of particular assumptions and ideas. So with kids who have become radicalized and they’ve taken on, let’s say, extremist thought, you can use Islamic sources to counter their extremism. So to prove to them using the same sources that they misuse, that what they’re doing is not right.
MINTZ
You’re talking about un-brainwashing.
SHAIKH
It assumes that the person is brainwashed. And perhaps the person has just sold themselves on a flimsy method of reason, if you want to call it that. Because they’re rational people. They read and they arrive at an argument. …
MINTZ
So who is a candidate for this?
SHAIKH
My dad runs the mosque. We actually started off doing crime prevention programs. The foundation is, to be a good Muslim is to be a good citizen. We make that synonymous with each other.

photo by Paul Terefenko
Guns For Terrorists
SHAIKH
The RCMP are very particular about that. There’s a whole process. They show me the letter. We’ve given you, basically, permission to commit these criminal offenses. But it’s only for this circumstance and it’s highly controlled.
MINTZ
What’s an example of that?
SHAIKH
Participating in a terrorist activity.
MINTZ
No, I mean like, you can j-walk, but don’t murder someone.
SHAIKH
Well, it was, you can be a participant of a terrorist group.
MINTZ
Which is itself a crime.
SHAIKH
But you cannot destroy property. You cannot kill anybody. Or commit grievous bodily harm.
MINTZ
So what were you supposed to do if you were put in a position where …
SHAIKH
So here’s what happens. So while I’m still with CSIS, Zakaria Amara, the main guy, I have a gun license, so, he calls me to Tim Horton’s, of course, on Overly Boulevard, down from Iqbal foods, the one right at the corner there. He says to me, we need you to buy us a gun. I’m like, ok. He goes, so you gonna buy it. I’m like, sure. He sits back and says, good, that was a test. Now, I’ve just agreed to buy a rifle for this guy. And CSIS is like, holy crap.
MINTZ
Are you wired?
SHAIKH
No. With CSIS I’m not. So it’s like, what do I do? If I would have said no, that’s like, this guys an agent. See you later.
MINTZ
But if you say yes … ?
SHAIKH
You’re now purchasing guns for…
(We digress here. But yes, buying guns for terrorists before finding a way to get it back into law enforcement hands.)
Chocolate Bomb
SHAIKH
The Toronto 18 guys used chocolate as the codeword for home made explosives.
MINTZ
As in, “so we got the chocolate in the truck”?
SHAIKH
As in, “so we gonna make some chocolate?”
CSIS vs RCMP
SHAIKH
CSIS, they’re people with degrees, usually in anthropology, sociology, political science, whatever, so you can actually have a conversation with them. RCMP, not so much.
Tapped Phones
MINTZ
Do you have good relations with anyone at CSIS now?
SHEPHARD
It’s always a dance, with what you do. Definitely, I know people. But it’s a really hard beat, in that you’ve got a balance a lot of …
SHAIKH
Your phones are tapped, left right and centre, always. All your emails …
SHEPHARD
No, I don’t think …
SHAIKH
Are you kidding me? They illegally do stuff all the time. They really do.
SHEPHARD
You’re going to make that accusation?
SHAIKH
You know what? It’s well known that, if they have the technical capabilities to do it, they’ll do it.
MINTZ
So, your phone and email … ?
SHEPHARD
(to SHAIKH) Yours probably are. But yours probably aren’t illegally. I’m sure they have warrants to do that.
SHAIKH
Now?
SHEPHARD
With all due respect.
TEREFENKO
Maybe they’re spying on this meal.
SHAIKH
I understand that they need to make sure, just in case, who’s calling who …
SHEPHARD
I know. But there are laws to govern that.
SHAIKH
Yeah? I don’t have that much faith anymore.
